Skip to main content

Althea Gibson's Lost Performance 'I Should Care' on Ed Sullivan Show

A woman in a patterned dress sits, smiling, with blurred silhouettes of people in the background.

A recently shared black-and-white video clip takes us back to the evening of August 24, 1958. It's no ordinary night. The scene is set for Althea Gibson's appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show, a musical moment about to ripple through time. The stage is shared with adept bongo players, their rhythms creating a vibrant backdrop to the spectacle unfolding.

A woman in a beaded dress sings, silhouettes of two figures in the background.

Already a tennis legend, Gibson is about to reveal a different facet of her abilities. She launches into a rendition of "I Should Care," a piece that causes our hearts to resonate with every note. This classic melody, the brainchild of Sammy Cahn, Axel Stordahl, and Paul Weston from the 1940s, is transformed under Gibson's touch. The performance is elegant and emotive, her voice spinning the timeless lyrics into a fresh narrative.

"I Should Care" is woven with sentiment, a poignant exploration of unrequited love, and a lingering sense of what could have been. As Gibson sings, her rendition breathes new life into the tale of longing and regret. This universal experience connects with listeners on a deeply emotional level.

A woman in a beaded dress sings passionately, her shadow cast on a dark background.

Before this musical debut, Gibson was already a household name in tennis. Born in South Carolina, she made history after her Grand Slam victory, taking home trophies from the French Open and Wimbledon.

As the final chords of "I Should Care" echo through the studio, we glimpse Gibson in a new light. Known as an exceptional athlete, she now stands as an accomplished musician. The song may have ended, but its melody lingers, a testament to her limitless talent and versatility.

A woman in a patterned dress sings, silhouettes of two figures in the background.

In the years since this performance, Gibson's legacy has only grown stronger. She embodies fearlessness, resilience, and relentless determination, inspiring countless individuals with her life story. Her performance on the Ed Sullivan Show adds another vibrant thread to the rich tapestry of her accomplishments.

Today, as we look back at Gibson's performance, it is a powerful symbol of her ability to transcend boundaries. She demonstrated an unwavering resolve in every aspect of her life, whether it was her sporting achievements or musical talents. Remembering her rendition of "I Should Care," we find ourselves immersed in her narrative, an inspiring tale of relentless drive and success.